Big Inventory vs. Lean Stock: Should Your Business Always Have Everything in Stock or Keep Inventory Costs Low?

By Robert Muehlen | BusinessBear

Managing inventory is one of the biggest challenges for any business. Do you stock up on everything customers might need, so you never run out? Or do you keep inventory lean to control costs, even if it means occasionally running out of stock?

Both strategies have their pros and cons, and many businesses have failed by going too far in one direction. So, what’s the best approach? Let’s break it down.

1. The “Always in Stock” Strategy: Large Inventory, High Availability

Some companies believe in always having what customers need. They invest in big warehouses, large inventories, and fast restocking, ensuring customers never face an “Out of Stock” sign.

Companies That Keep Big Inventories

✅ Walmart – Uses a massive supply chain to keep shelves stocked across thousands of stores.

✅ Amazon – Invests billions in warehouses so customers can get almost anything overnight.

✅ Costco – Keeps bulk stock of high-demand items, ensuring customers can buy in large quantities.

👍 Pros of Keeping Large Inventory

✔ Never lose a sale – If customers always find what they need, they won’t go to competitors.

✔ Better customer satisfaction – People appreciate reliability.

✔ Can handle demand spikes – Big sales events (like Black Friday) won’t cause stock shortages.

👎 Cons of Keeping Large Inventory

❌ High storage costs – Warehouses, rent, and inventory management add up.

❌ Risk of unsold products – If demand changes, you might be stuck with outdated stock.

❌ Cash flow issues – Money tied up in inventory can’t be used elsewhere.

2. The Lean Inventory Strategy: Cost Control, But Risk of Stockouts

Other companies take a different approach. Instead of keeping large amounts of stock, they manage lean inventories—only stocking what’s necessary and reordering based on demand.

📌 Companies That Keep Lean Inventories

✅ Zara (Fast Fashion) – Uses a just-in-time inventory model, making small batches of clothing and restocking based on real-time sales.

✅ Toyota (Car Manufacturing) – Pioneered the lean inventory system, keeping parts stocked only as needed to cut storage costs.

✅ Apple – Keeps limited stock of new products, creating demand and excitement (but sometimes frustrating customers).

👍 Pros of Keeping Lean Inventory

✔ Lower costs – Less money tied up in unsold products.

✔ More flexibility – Easier to adjust to changing trends.

✔ Less waste – Reduces risk of stock becoming outdated.

👎 Cons of Keeping Lean Inventory

❌ Risk of running out of stock – Customers might go elsewhere if you don’t have what they need.

❌ Longer wait times – If a product is out of stock, restocking can take time.

❌ Lost revenue opportunities – Running out of inventory during peak demand can be costly.

3. What Happens When These Strategies Fail?

Many companies have made huge mistakes by going too far in either direction.

📉 Failed by Keeping Too Much Inventory

🚨 Blockbuster – In the early 2000s, Blockbuster kept huge inventories of DVDs in stores. But when streaming services took over, they were stuck with millions of unsold DVDs and massive rental store costs. This was a big reason for their downfall.

🚨 Toys “R” Us Canada – The company held large inventories of toys but struggled when customer demand shifted to online shopping. They couldn’t move stock fast enough and had too much money tied up in warehouses, leading to bankruptcy.

🚨 Forever 21 – The fashion retailer stocked huge amounts of clothing, assuming customers would keep buying fast fashion. But as trends changed and customers wanted sustainable options, they couldn’t sell outdated stock and lost billions.

📉 Failed by Keeping Too Little Inventory

🚨 Sony PlayStation 5 (PS5) Shortages – Sony underestimated demand for the PS5, and lean inventory planning caused worldwide shortages. Customers waited months (or even years) to get one, leading many to buy from scalpers instead of Sony.

🚨 KFC’s UK Chicken Shortage – In 2018, KFC in the UK switched suppliers to cut costs, but the new system failed, leading to massive chicken shortages. Customers were outraged, and hundreds of stores had to temporarily close due to lack of stock.

🚨 Loblaws (Canada) Grocery Stock Issues – During supply chain disruptions, Loblaws tried to minimize costs by reducing stock levels on certain items. This backfired when customers couldn’t find basic necessities during peak demand periods.

4. So, Which Strategy Is Better?

🔹 If you sell essential or high-demand products (like groceries, electronics, or household goods), keeping stock available is critical.

🔹 If you sell seasonal, fast-moving, or trend-based products (like fashion), lean inventory can help prevent waste.

🔹 The best approach is a balance—keeping key products in stock while managing slow-moving items carefully.

💡 The Winning Strategy? A Smart Inventory Mix

The most successful companies combine both strategies:

✅ Amazon: Uses big inventories for essentials but lean inventory for trend-based products.

✅ Nike & Adidas: Keep high stock of core products (like classic sneakers) but use limited stock for special releases to drive demand.

✅ Canadian Tire: Balances stock between high-demand items (always in stock) and seasonal goods (limited quantities to avoid excess).

From my personal perspective, especially when it comes to small businesses and startups, I firmly believe that you should always have merchandise in stock. As a small business owner, you've already done all the hard work—marketing, attracting customers, and getting them through your doors or onto your website. The last thing you want is for them to leave empty-handed simply because the item they were looking for isn’t available. Unlike big companies that have brand loyalty and multiple store locations, small businesses can’t afford to miss a sale due to poor inventory management. If a customer walks in and doesn’t find what they need, there’s a high chance they won’t come back—they’ll simply go to a competitor, and you might lose them forever. While I understand that keeping inventory costs controlled is important, the lost sales, disappointed customers, and damaged reputation from being out of stock can be far more costly in the long run.

Whether you're a retailer, wholesaler, or eCommerce business, we can help you find the perfect inventory balance for sustainable growth.

5. How BusinessBear Can Help You with Inventory Strategy

At BusinessBear, we help startups and small businesses create inventory strategies that maximize sales while controlling costs.

We specialize in:

✅ Inventory forecasting – Predicting how much stock you need to avoid running out or overstocking.

✅ Supply chain optimization – Finding cost-effective ways to keep products in stock.

✅ Cost-saving strategies – Reducing waste and improving cash flow.

✅ Balancing stock levels – Ensuring you always have what customers need without overspending.

Final Thoughts: Inventory Is a Balancing Act

Inventory is one of the most important but challenging aspects of running a business.

A great inventory strategy helps you:

✅ Keep customers happy by always having what they need.

✅ Avoid overstocking and wasting money on storage.

✅ Make sure you have stock available during peak demand.

✅ Stay flexible so you can adapt to market changes.

💡 Want to optimize your inventory and avoid costly mistakes? Contact BusinessBear today to create a smarter inventory strategy!

BusinessBear.ca